Best Insurance Reviews in New Castle, Pennsylvania

We love feedback from our clients, it's the only way we can really know if we are delivering great service, and it's the only way for others to know what we mean when we say we provide service that exceeds expectations.

Reviews from Around the Web:

• CCarrie Goff reviewed Williams-Cleaveland Company on Google:
  Mar 01, 2024
  ★★★★★
  I have consistently received excellent service from Williams Cleavland Agency. Judy Capots is extremely efficient, always pleasant and handles my requests to my satisfaction. Everyone that I talk to there gets 5 stars. Thank you so much!... Read More.
• KKellie Hinderliter reviewed Williams-Cleaveland Company on Google:
  Jan 05, 2024
  ★★★★★
  Kellie Hinderliter gave Williams-Cleaveland Company a 5 star rating on Google
• LLesedy Gakeitumele reviewed Williams-Cleaveland Company on Facebook:
  Jul 20, 2023
  ★★★★★
  I used to have a lot of concerns about trading since there are lots of risks involved, so I've made it a point to only work with regulated platform. That's how I discovered MRS ELIZABETH BAYS platform. From what I've gathered by now, this platform seems legit. My experience has been completely positive so far, successful withdrawal... Read More.
• JJim Lombardo reviewed Williams-Cleaveland Company on Google:
  Jul 11, 2023
  ★★★★★
  Judy always goes above and beyond in helping me with all my insurance needs.
• EEbah Krou reviewed Williams-Cleaveland Company on Facebook:
  Oct 14, 2022
  ★★★★★
  My colleague referred me to MRS. Kristina Scott. He and his family congratulated her and said she was friendly with the military, so I decided to contact her. From the first interaction, I was very satisfied. She was clearly very knowledgeable and seemed dedicated to her clients. At the start of my investment I was apprehensive about... Read More.
• JJOHN MILLER reviewed Williams-Cleaveland Company on Google:
  Sep 13, 2022
  ★★★★★
  They have always gone out of there way to help our family, even on holiday weekends!
• BBruce Altman reviewed Williams-Cleaveland Company on Google:
  Apr 01, 2022
  ★★★★★
  Bruce Altman gave Williams-Cleaveland Company a 5 star rating on Google
• LLaura Huffman reviewed Williams-Cleaveland Company on Google:
  Feb 24, 2022
  ★★★★★
  Laura Huffman gave Williams-Cleaveland Company a 5 star rating on Google
• CChelsea Harding reviewed Williams-Cleaveland Company on Google:
  Aug 03, 2021
  ★★★★★
  Chelsea Harding gave Williams-Cleaveland Company a 5 star rating on Google
• SScott Penwell reviewed Williams-Cleaveland Company on Google:
  Jul 30, 2021
  ★★★★★
  The whole staff is great to work with,very professional ,especially our agent Judy Capots who always has time to answer any question on our ever changing insurance needs, definitely would recommend the Williams Cleveland Company in New Castle... Read More.
• JJohn Flores reviewed Williams-Cleaveland Company on Google:
  Jul 30, 2021
  ★★★★★
  Always there when we need them rain or shine
• UUndeadXFate reviewed Williams-Cleaveland Company on Google:
  May 04, 2021
  ★★★★★
  UndeadXFate gave Williams-Cleaveland Company a 5 star rating on Google
• JJennifer G reviewed Williams-Cleaveland Company on Google:
  Apr 12, 2021
  ★★★★★
  Following a fire at my condo, Glenn and Judy went above and beyond to help me navigate both the claims and restoration process. They made a very stressful situation manageable and I will always be grateful for their support and guidance.... Read More.
• KKaitlyn Stoyer reviewed Williams-Cleaveland Company on Google:
  Mar 18, 2021
  ★★★★★
  Kaitlyn Stoyer gave Williams-Cleaveland Company a 5 star rating on Google
• Pphillip bartolone reviewed Williams-Cleaveland Company on Google:
  Mar 18, 2021
  ★★★★★
  phillip bartolone gave Williams-Cleaveland Company a 5 star rating on Google
• RRene Smith reviewed Williams-Cleaveland Company on Google:
  Mar 17, 2021
  ★★★★★
  Judy at Williams-Cleaveland has handled my insurance for several homes in Western Pa and has always been amazing to work with, very responsive to any communication and completely professional. I've always received estimates from several agencies when purchasing property and she has always come back with the best policy and price. I h... Read More.
• EE-Z Kleen Car & Van Wash reviewed Williams-Cleaveland Company on Google:
  Mar 17, 2021
  ★★★★★
  Great service! Judy and Shainna went out of there way to help me. Recommend this place to anyone in need of personal or business insurance needs.... Read More.
• JJoEllen Thomas reviewed Williams-Cleaveland Company on Google:
  Feb 08, 2021
  ★★★★★
  I highly recommend Williams-Cleaveland Company to anyone looking for home owners, life, or auto insurance. Judy was able to find me a great rate for my insurance and anytime I have needed a change, it is fast and easily done. All the staff is very kind, helpful and professional. I'm treated as a friend, not just a customer. Thank... Read More.
• CCaplan R reviewed Williams-Cleaveland Company on Google:
  Nov 12, 2020
  ★★★★★
  I have been a customer of Williams-Cleaveland Co. for many years; both with personal and commercial coverages. Glenn, Rosanne, and the team have always taken care of every single insurance need and then go above and beyond with personal attention. I recently experienced a residential damage claim, and the assistance I received here w... Read More.
• RRobert Lyles reviewed Williams-Cleaveland Company on Facebook:
  Mar 17, 2020
  ★★★★★
  Experience and Customer Service second to none!!!!
• Ccolleen gillen reviewed Williams-Cleaveland Company on Google:
  Jan 31, 2020
  ★★★★★
  The team at WCI is professional and great at their jobs! Shayna introduced me to Judy when i was buying a house. She got my homeowners at a great rate and saved me $50 on my car insurance.... Read More.
• JJoshua Kauffman reviewed Williams-Cleaveland Company on Facebook:
  Oct 22, 2019
  ★★★★★
  I recently made a claim for a car accident that I was a part of. Judy Capots was with me every step of the way and was able to facilitate conversations and communication between me and all of my claim representatives from Travelers Insurance. She made the process very simple and stress free!! I would 100% recommend Williams-Cleavelan... Read More.
• BBrandon Ratvasky reviewed Williams-Cleaveland Company on Facebook:
  Aug 28, 2019
  ★★★★★
  Fantastic service from everyone. Start to Finish. Have purchased business, home, and auto insurance and have been satisfied with all of it! 5 outta 5 stars... Read More.
• LLindall Applegate reviewed Williams-Cleaveland Company on Google:
  Apr 01, 2019
  ★★★★★
  For our business, Williams Cleaveland Co. has been an asset. They seek to find coverage we require and offer improvements to our policies as needed. Their friendly knowledgeable Representatives are always ready to answer any concerns or questions we have. We appreciate the pleasant service we receive from Williams Cleaveland Company... Read More.
• LLori Jeannette reviewed Williams-Cleaveland Company on Facebook:
  Feb 16, 2018
  ★★★★★
  Great office and staff! Only wants the best for their customers!
• MMarvin S. reviewed Williams-Cleaveland Company on Yelp:
  Dec 26, 2017
  ★★★★★
  Judy Capots was a huge help to us during our stressful move and got everything in order for the transition. She took care of home, auto, and boat and gave us direction on how to transfer from one state to another. Thanks for the continued support!... Read More.
• CClaire V. reviewed Williams-Cleaveland Company on Yelp:
  Nov 15, 2017
  ★★★★★
  Moving into a new home can be quite frustrating. However, when working with Judy Capots, it was so simple and stress free! She was great to work with and help us understand all the various ways to insure our property. Our experience was wonderful!... Read More.
• RRyan M. reviewed Williams-Cleaveland Company on Yelp:
  Oct 08, 2017
  ★★★★★
  Judy is a wonderful person to work with! She made getting car insurance so easy, and answered all my questions and helped me find a policy that worked for me!... Read More.
• JJoni K. reviewed Williams-Cleaveland Company on Yelp:
  Oct 08, 2017
  ★★★★★
  Judy is the best! Everyone in my family goes to her for all of our insurance needs :)
• AAnthony C. reviewed Williams-Cleaveland Company on Yelp:
  Sep 26, 2017
  ★★★★★
  Excellent and very knowledgeable. I spoke with Marcie. She was very friendly. I have been with my home and auto insurance for many years and will continue to insure with them.... Read More.
• EEvan L. reviewed Williams-Cleaveland Company on Yelp:
  Sep 25, 2017
  ★★★★★
  Williams-Cleaveland Company is an excellent insurance agency. I will never do business with anyone other than Marcie! She is knowledgeable, friendly, & has my best interest in mind at all times. Williams Cleaveland Company & Marcie has my business!! Thanks for great service!!... Read More.
• KKayla K. reviewed Williams-Cleaveland Company on Yelp:
  Aug 28, 2017
  ★★★★★
  When purchasing my condo, I had no idea what most of the terms meant, didn't understand policies, and wasn't sure what coverage I needed. Judy was able to answer all of questions quickly, and helped guide me in the right direction. She is very professional, and I could tell she had my best interest in mind. :) I will definitely be go... Read More.
• CCassie C. reviewed Williams-Cleaveland Company on Yelp:
  Aug 15, 2017
  ★★★★★
  My husband and I just purchased our first home and needed to purchase homeowners' insurance. Judy was extremely helpful in assisting us with the proper coverage, as well as ensuring that we received the coverage in time for our mortgage approval. Highly recommend using WIlliams-Cleaveland for your insurance needs.... Read More.
• JJaci M. reviewed Williams-Cleaveland Company on Yelp:
  Aug 09, 2017
  ★★★★★
  i would highly recomend williams cleaveland insurance. Marcie lambert did an awesome job on getting us a quote that works best for us. Thank you so much for your help.... Read More.
• AAmber C. reviewed Williams-Cleaveland Company on Yelp:
  Jun 25, 2017
  ★★★★★
  I am so pleased with the service I've received at Williams-Cleaveland! The staff is very friendly and they always know how to help me with what I need. I have recommended and will continue to recommend them to people I know!... Read More.
• JJustin C. reviewed Williams-Cleaveland Company on Yelp:
  May 09, 2017
  ★★★★★
  After having our car insurance rates go up dramatically, for no known reason, my wife and I decided to work with Williams-Cleaveland to see if they could find us a better rate (we typically try to find something on our own). We worked with Judy for both car insurance and renters insurance. Not only was she always available to answer... Read More.
• KKim C. reviewed Williams-Cleaveland Company on Yelp:
  Apr 17, 2017
  ★★★★★
  I have been a client for several years. Marcie is very knowledgeable and provides excellent customer service. She answers all my questions and provides me with options. Reviews my accounts in detail and offers me coverages that may be beneficial for me to have that I currently do not have. Very professional.... Read More.
• AAshley S. reviewed Williams-Cleaveland Company on Yelp:
  Apr 14, 2017
  ★★★★★
  Excellent service and very knowledgeable! Every issue I've had has been handled with professionalism, reassurance, and friendliness!... Read More.
• GGladys A. reviewed Williams-Cleaveland Company on Yelp:
  Jun 01, 2016
  ★★★★★
  Glenn Lebby from Williams-Cleaveland follows through with every question, returnsevery phone call and this firm is very professional. You will be very satisfied with theirorganization.... Read More.
• KKim Oblak Conti reviewed Williams-Cleaveland Company on Facebook:
  Mar 16, 2016
  ★★★★★
  Great Company! I was in the office to review my policy with Marcie Lambert. She was very helpful. She offered coverage's that I didn't know I didn't have. Great job!... Read More.
• AAshley Marie reviewed Williams-Cleaveland Company on Facebook:
  Mar 01, 2016
  ★★★★★
  Extremely knowledgeable and always willing to help with any problems! I always feel comfortable and we'll taken care of when I'm there! I highly recommend them!... Read More.
• RRene Beans reviewed Williams-Cleaveland Company on Facebook:
  Mar 01, 2016
  ★★★★★
  Extremely helpful, informative, knowledgeable and friendly personnel. Highly recommend.
• SSara Petrick Sloan reviewed Williams-Cleaveland Company on Facebook:
  Feb 11, 2016
  ★★★★★
  I had excellent service from Marcie this week! Her attention to my insurance quotes was great. She answered all of my questions very quickly and was very informative about the products they offer!!!... Read More.
• MMarcie Lambert reviewed Williams-Cleaveland Company on Facebook:
  Jan 22, 2016
  ★★★★★
  Marcie Lambert gave Williams-Cleaveland Company a 5 star rating on Facebook
• KKevin M. reviewed Williams-Cleaveland Company on Yelp:
  Jul 20, 2010
  ★★★★★
  The Yelp listing for this insurance agency shows 'closed', which it most certainly not. Yelp has been notified and hopefully will correct the error. The agency has provided insurance consultation and products, for both personal and business, continuously for over 110 years.... Read More.
• WWhitney P. reviewed Williams-Cleaveland Company on Yelp:
  Aug 01, 2017
  ★☆☆☆☆
  I work for an insurance company and, unfortunately, had to speak with this office regarding a business matter. I spoke with both Shanna and Judy. I have never spoken with anyone more unprofessional in my ten years in this industry.... Read More.